Advertiser Disclosure

Medicare 101: Demystifying the Birthday Rule

4 mins read
Our goal is to give you the tools and confidence you need to improve your health and finances. Although we may receive compensation from our partner insurance companies, whom we will always identify, all opinions are our own. CoverRight Inc. and CoverRight Insurance Services Inc. (NPN: 19724057) are collectively referred to here as "CoverRight".

Navigating the nuances of Medicare can often feel like decoding a complex puzzle, especially when it comes to understanding the various rules and regulations that govern it. One such aspect that frequently puzzles beneficiaries is the ‘Birthday Rule’.

Though not widely discussed, the Birthday Rule is a crucial element in Medicare, particularly for those considering or currently enrolled in Medigap (Medicare Supplement Insurance) plans.

The Medicare Birthday Rule pertains to Medigap policies and offers an annual opportunity for beneficiaries to switch their Medigap plans without medical underwriting. This rule allows for a more flexible and beneficiary-friendly approach to managing Medigap coverage, especially around a beneficiary’s birthday.

In this post, we provide a clear and comprehensive understanding of what the Birthday Rule insurance Medicare entails, how it can benefit you as a Medigap policyholder, and what you need to know to make informed decisions about your healthcare coverage. 

How Does the Medigap Birthday Rule Affect Me?

The Birthday Rule is a significant aspect of Medigap that directly impacts beneficiaries looking to manage or change their supplemental insurance coverage.

Here’s how it works and its implications:

Interaction with Medigap and Limitations:

The Birthday Rule allows Medigap policyholders to switch to another Medigap plan with the same or lesser benefits without undergoing medical underwriting. This opportunity arises annually around the beneficiary’s birthday.

The rule aims to protect beneficiaries from being locked into a Medigap plan that may no longer meet their needs or budget.

The Birthday Rule typically provides a 30-day window following your birthday to make a switch. Importantly, it only applies to switches where the new plan has the same or lesser benefits, preventing upgrades without underwriting. 

This rule does not apply to Medicare Advantage plans but only to Medigap policies.

States With the Birthday Rule and Their Respective Regulations

Currently, eight US states offer a Medigap Birthday Rule, each with its distinct regulations. 

  1. California:
  • The California Birthday Rule applies to all residents with an existing Medigap policy.
  • The window for changes starts 30 days before the birthday and extends 60 days after. This gives beneficiaries a 90-day period to switch plans.
  • Policyholders can switch to any plan of equal or lesser benefit with any carrier, without health underwriting questions.
  1. Oregon:
  • Oregon’s rule allows policyholders to switch to any plan of equal or lesser benefit with any carrier, similar to California’s rule.
  • The rule is active from the date of birth and lasts for 31 days.
  1. Idaho:
  • In Idaho, the Birthday Rule lasts 63 days, starting on the beneficiary’s birthday.
  • Beneficiaries can enroll in any plan of equal or lesser benefit with any carrier.
  1. Illinois:
  • The rule in Illinois applies to beneficiaries aged 65 to 75 years.
  • It allows for enrollment in a plan from the current carrier, provided the new plan does not exceed the benefit level of the current plan. The window opens on the birthday and lasts for 45 days.
  1. Louisiana:
  • The Louisiana Birthday Rule provides a 93-day window, starting 30 days before the birthday and ending 63 days after.
  • It allows changes to a policy of equal or lesser benefit through the current carrier.
  1. Maryland:
  • Maryland’s rule begins on the birthday and extends for 31 days thereafter.
  • Residents can enroll in a Medigap plan of equal or lesser value without health underwriting during this period.
  1. Nevada:
  • The rule opens on the first day of the beneficiary’s birth month and lasts at least 61 days.
  • Policyholders can change their Medigap carrier or plan, provided the new policy is of equal or lesser benefit.
  1. Oklahoma:
  • Oklahoma offers a 60-day window starting from the birthday.
  • It allows changes to another Medigap plan of equal or lesser value without medical underwriting.

How Can I Take Advantage of the Birthday Rule?

Understanding and utilizing the Birthday Rule can be a great way to ensure your Medigap plan continues to meet your healthcare needs.

To make the most of this opportunity, follow these steps:

  • Know Your State’s Specific Rule: Familiarize yourself with the Birthday Rule as it applies in your state, including the window for making changes and any restrictions on plan choices.
  • Assess Your Current Coverage: Review your existing Medigap plan to determine if it still fits your healthcare needs and budget. Consider any changes in your health or finances since you first enrolled.
  • Explore Available Options: Research other Medigap plans that offer similar or lesser benefits during the Birthday Rule window. Compare their costs, coverage, and any additional benefits they might offer.
  • Consult with Experts: Navigating the complexities of Medigap plans can be challenging. Services like CoverRight can provide expert advice and support in this process. They can help you understand your options, compare different plans, and assist in transitioning to a new plan.
  • Act Within the Window: Make sure to complete your Medigap plan switch within the timeframe allowed by the Birthday Rule in your state to take advantage of this opportunity without needing medical underwriting.

For personalized assistance in leveraging the Birthday Rule for your Medigap coverage, reach out to CoverRight. We’re here to guide you through each step, making the process clear and manageable.

Contact CoverRight today to optimize your Medigap plan during your birthday rule window.


How does the Birthday Rule benefit Medicare beneficiaries?

This rule benefits beneficiaries by providing an annual opportunity to reassess and possibly change their Medigap plan based on current health needs or financial circumstances, without restrictions due to medical underwriting.

Are all states required to follow the Birthday Rule in Medicare Insurance?

No, the Birthday Rule is not federally mandated and is only available in certain states. Each participating state has its specific rules and regulations regarding this policy.

Can I upgrade to a plan with more benefits under the Birthday Rule?

Generally, the Birthday Rule allows you to switch to a plan with the same or fewer benefits. Upgrading to a plan with more benefits typically requires going through medical underwriting.

When is the best time to make a change under the Birthday Rule insurance Medicare?

The best time to make a change is during the specific window provided by your state’s Birthday Rule, which usually starts on your birthday and lasts for a limited period. Acting within this timeframe is important to take advantage of the rule.

Connor Wilson

Connor is a Content Writer at CoverRight focused on editing and publishing Medicare and health insurance-related information. He also serves the team as a Business Operations Lead, working to expand the business and enhance its strategy. Prior to joining CoverRight, Connor was able to hone his knowledge of the financial services industry through his work in investment banking. Additionally, he is the self-published author of a mystery novel.

Latest from Blog